Day 6: November 16
Greetings from Antalya and COP31!
Week 2 of COP kicked off appropriately enough, with the publication of the first draft of a cover decision that would convey the political consensus from this summit.
As many observers noted, it's more or less a grab-bag of everyone's positive wishes, and it's a racing certainty that some of the contents will at least lead to intense disagreement.
The cover text runs to 18 pages and covers the temperature overshoot, finance, mitigation, adaptation, mountains, small island developing states – and it even has a good word to say on markets (in paragraph 139).
There's also room at the moment to welcome Turkey's 35% by 2035 electrification pledge, Brazil's Transition Away from Fossil Fuels roadmaps, and quite a few more references to fossil fuels that may or may not last the course.
President of Negotiations Chris Bowen said the text had been issued much earlier than usual to enable plenty of time for conversation and negotiation to allow the strongest possible outcome.
Bowen told a press conference there were around 30 negotiating mandates that are still to be concluded, while delegates have reached agreement on a further 48 items.
The Presidency will lead consultations on the cover text, while five pairs of ministers are tasked with leading discussions on specific issues:
Our carbon markets discussions are still being held at a more technical level and do not yet need political supervision.
Elsewhere on Monday, UNFCCC Executive Secretary Simon Stiell said that methodologies and standards developed under the PACM could act as benchmarks for carbon markets around the world. He noted that the CORSIA market regulator has provisionally cleared PACM to supply credits to the aviation market.
In the negotiations
Negotiations resumed on Monday morning with an informal consultation on the Report of the Supervisory Body (SBM).
The disagreement over the rigour of methodologies and standards under PACM has had some coverage in the specialist media over the last couple of days, and there was an op-ed on the matter in the climate Action network's daily ECO newsletter, titled "Strict is a feature, not a bug".
We've been at pains to stress that the degree of strictness is such that so far, there have been just a handful of projects registered under PACM and this is also choking the flow of funding to developing countries, who are relying on Article 6 to help drive their low-carbon transitions.
Or as Andrea Bonzanni expressed it in a post on LinkedIn, "the SBM is building a mechanism that can only work for a small number of activities and for Parties that are willing to pay very high prices. To be clear, at the moment there is no Party that is willing to pay these prices."
Parties including the Like-Minded Developing Countries, the Least-Developed Countries, Brazil, the Latin American and Caribbean group, Norway and Indonesia have all registered their unhappiness with the state of PACM methodologies, while the EU is holding fast to the strict standards that are currently in place.
The 6.4 consultations were set to resume this evening, since there remained a long list of Parties wishing to speak. There were also informals on Article 6.2 funding and the Article 6.2 guidance scheduled for later in the day.
The Presidency has asked negotiations on Article 6 to conclude by tomorrow (Tuesday), which our team thinks is a bit of a stretch...
Today at COP31
Björn Fonden joined a high-level panel with the Minister of Environment of Somalia, the African Union and others to explore the development of carbon markets in Somalia. As one of the least-developed countries in the world, Somalia is now opening up for carbon financing through the voluntary market and Article 6 to mobilise investments and support the achievement of their NDC with the launch of their new national framework.
At the IETA Pavilion, YC Holdings organised a well-attended side-event with perspectives from Indonesia, Vietnam, Malaysia, Taiwan and IETA's Björn Fondén on the acceleration of compliance pricing regimes across the region. The event highlighted several new emissions trading schemes in the region, their different design elements and future opportunities for stronger harmonisation.
Elisa Guida joined a meeting of the Open Coalition for Compliance Carbon Markets, which welcomed two new members (Korea and Indonesia) and 18 new observers.
The meeting discussed the COP31 declaration and the priorities for 2027, among them the launch of the working groups, focused on: ETS design and market convergence, MRV and accounting and use of high-integrity offsets.
IETA is already an observer and was mentioned as one of the Coalition's volunteers in the working groups.
We also attended a high-level event featuring Diana Acconcia of the European Union, ministers from Chile and Bolivia and senior officials from Colombia. Both sides said they are willing to cooperate on carbon pricing and Article 6, though it is still early days in this particular discussion.
The UNFCCC also held an event to update on progress in developing the international registry (Article 6.2), which you can watch here.
Tomorrow at COP31
All event times are listed in Antalya time (TST), which is three hours ahead of GMT and five hours behind Singapore time.
The IETA Business Pavilion is located in Delegation Pavilion Area B2, on stand C525. Our Boardroom is in the Delegation Office area C3, stand DO-17.
Things are beginning to calm down slightly as Week 2 gets under way, and the programme at the IETA Business Hub is a little lighter on Tuesday. Equally, market-oriented side events elsewhere are thinner on the ground but after the packed schedules on Friday and Saturday, perhaps we shouldn't be greedy.
Tomorrow around Antalya and in the COP venue, we'll be watching these events:
At the IETA Business Hub, we'll turn our attention to legal matters and finance: